Choosing a restaurant POS comes down to four questions: Do you need dual pricing? Native online ordering? A bundled KDS? And how important is negotiating your processing rate? Here's how the top systems compare.
Most restaurant POS comparisons get tangled in feature lists. The decision is actually simpler than that. Four questions drive most choices:
1. Do you need dual pricing or cash discount? (Toast doesn't support it; Square doesn't either)
2. Do you need native online ordering? (Toast wins; Clover requires apps)
3. How important is negotiating your processing rate? (Toast locks you in; Square is flat-rate; Clover gives you choice)
4. Do you need a full-service workflow or just reliable payment acceptance?
Answer those four and the right system usually becomes clear.
Best for: Full-service and quick-service restaurants wanting processor flexibility and a large app ecosystem.
Clover is the most-deployed restaurant and retail POS in the US, backed by Fiserv. It's not built exclusively for restaurants — it works equally well for retail — which gives it the broadest hardware ecosystem and the largest app marketplace (300+ integrations).
The key advantage: you choose your processor. That means Fibi can negotiate your rates across multiple processors, often landing at 1.5–2.3% for volume accounts versus the 2.6%+ flat rate of Square or the locked rate of Toast Payments.
Dual pricing is configurable through eligible processors — Fibi sets this up as standard for qualifying clients.
Hardware: Station Duo (dual-screen, $1,649+), Mini ($599+), Kiosk ($1,799+), Flex (handheld), Go (mobile)
Contract: Typically 3 years Processor: Your choice — negotiableBest for: Dedicated full-service restaurants prioritizing native workflow depth over processing flexibility.
Toast is purpose-built for restaurants and leads on native functionality: table mapping, coursing, Toast Online ordering, Toast TakeOut app, and built-in loyalty. For a complex full-service restaurant where workflow depth is the priority, Toast's native tools are strong.
The critical limitation: Toast Payments is mandatory. You cannot bring your own processor or negotiate rates externally. If you process $30,000+/month, the rate you're locked into versus a negotiated rate can be $300–$900/month — worth modeling before you sign.
Hardware: Toast POS terminal, Toast Kiosk, Toast Go 2 Contract: Typically 2 years Processor: Toast Payments — mandatory, non-negotiable
Best for: Multi-location businesses, franchise operators, and restaurants where dual pricing and KDS are central.
Curv POS builds dual pricing, KDS (kitchen display system), and virtual terminal into the platform natively — no add-ons, no third-party integrations required. The restaurant bundle (workstation + tablet + KDS + cash drawer) ships as a single order.
For a restaurant where dual pricing is central to the business model and a bundled KDS matters, Curv POS often edges Clover on total value at setup.
Hardware: Restaurant Bundle — workstation + tablet + KDS + cash drawer Contract: Contact Fibi for terms Processor: Via Fibi relationship — rate negotiated
Curv POS overview → | Curv POS vs Clover comparison →
Best for: New restaurants, food trucks, and low-volume operations wanting zero commitment.
Square is the fastest to set up and the only major POS with no contract requirement. The base Square Reader works immediately. No processor enrollment. No hardware order. No multi-week wait.
The trade-offs: no dual pricing support, flat-rate pricing that becomes expensive above $10,000/month, and no dedicated account support for most SMBs. For a restaurant just opening or processing under $10,000/month, Square's simplicity is genuinely valuable. For any established restaurant with meaningful volume, the economics argue for Clover or Curv POS.
Hardware: Free reader, Terminal ($299), Register ($799) Contract: None — month-to-month Processor: Square Payments — flat rate only
| Feature | Clover | Toast | Curv POS | Square |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dual pricing | Yes (via processor) | No | Yes (native) | No |
| Native online ordering | Via apps | Yes | Via apps | Square Online |
| KDS | Separate hardware | Native | Included in bundle | Separate |
| Processing flexibility | Full — choose processor | Locked to Toast | Negotiated via Fibi | Flat rate |
| Contract | 3 years | 2 years | Contact Fibi | None |
| Best effective rate | 1.5–2.3% negotiated | Non-negotiable | Negotiated | 2.6% + flat |
| Kiosk | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Choose Clover if:
Your restaurant needs a proven platform with processor flexibility, a 300+ app ecosystem, and the option to configure dual pricing. The dominant choice for restaurants with $15,000+/month in card volume.
Choose Toast if:
You run a dedicated full-service restaurant and native online ordering and complex FOH workflow are the top priorities. Accept the processing lock-in as a known trade-off.
Choose Curv POS if:
Dual pricing is central to your model, KDS needs to be included in the bundle, and you want multi-location reporting from day one. Strongest for dual pricing deployments.
Choose Square if:
You're opening, testing, or processing low volume. Zero commitment, same-day setup, and free hardware to start are genuinely valuable in those scenarios.
See the full side-by-side comparisons:
Free analysis — we compare 300+ providers at your exact address.
Get a Free Quote